Running Systems

It has been long since I had the time to write here. I have recently been involved more and more with XenServer virtualization, as you might see in the blogs, and following a solution to a rather common problem, I have decided to post it here.

The problem: When attempting to boot a Linux VM on XenServer (5.0 and 5.5), you get the following error message:

Error: Starting VM ‘Cacti’ – Internal error: Failure(“Error from xenguesthelper: caught exception: Failure(\\\”Subprocess failure: Failure(\\\\\\\”xc_dom_linux_build: [2] xc_dom_find_loader: no loader found\\\\\\\\n\\\\\\\”)\\\”)”)

This is very common with Linux VMs which were converted from physical (or other, non-PV virtualization) to XenServer.

This will probably either happen during the P2V process, or after a successful update to the Linux VM.

The cause is that the original kernel, non PV-aware one, has not been removed, and GRUB likes to load from it. XenServer will use the GRUB menu, but will not display it to us to select our desired kernel.

With no chance to intervene, XenServer will attempt to load a PV-enabled machine using non-PV kernel, and will fail.

Preventing the problem is quite simple – remove your non-PV kernel (non-xen) so that future updates will not attempt to update it as well and set it to be the default kernel. Very simple.

Solving the problem in less than two minutes is a bit more tricky. Let’s see how to solve it.

All operations are performed from within the control domain. This guide does not apply to StorageLink or NetApp/Equalogic devices, as they behave differently. This applies only to LVM-over-something, whatever it may be.

First, we will need to find the name of the VDI we are to work on. Use xe in the following manner, using the VM’s name:

xe vbd-list vm-name-label=Cacti

uuid ( RO)             : 128f29dc-4a14-1a2d-75d1-8674d3d2403b
vm-uuid ( RO): eae053de-4a20-28a5-f335-f5a18dd79993
vm-name-label ( RO): Cacti
vdi-uuid ( RO): 90524af4-5b20-4412-9bfe-f1fe27f220b1
empty ( RO): false
device ( RO): xvda

uuid ( RO)             : de177727-b28a-8b79-e73e-d08366d56277
vm-uuid ( RO): eae053de-4a20-28a5-f335-f5a18dd79993
vm-name-label ( RO): Cacti
vdi-uuid ( RO): <not in database>
empty ( RO): true
device ( RO): xvdd

It is very common that xvdd is used for CDROM, so we can safely ignore the second section. The first section is the more interesting one. There is a correlation between the name of the VDI and the name of the LVM on the disk. We can find this specific LV using the following command. Notice that the name of the VDI is used here as the argument for the ‘grep’ command:

lvs | grep 90524af4-5b20-4412-9bfe-f1fe27f220b1

LV-90524af4-5b20-4412-9bfe-f1fe27f220b1 VG_XenStorage-4aa20fc2-fd92-20c2-c549-bed2597c622b -wi-a-  10.00G

We now have our LV path! As you can see, its status is offline. We need to set it to online state. Using both the LV and the VG name, we can do it like that:

lvchange -ay /dev/VG_XenStorage-4aa20fc2-fd92-20c2-c549-bed2597c622b/LV-90524af4-5b20-4412-9bfe-f1fe27f220b1

Now we can access the volume. We can actually check that the problem is the one we look for, using pygrub:

pygrub /dev/VG_XenStorage-4aa20fc2-fd92-20c2-c549-bed2597c622b/LV-90524af4-5b20-4412-9bfe-f1fe27f220b1

We should now see the GRUB menu of the VM at question. If you don’t see any menu, either you have missed a step or used the wrong disk.

The menu should show you all the list of kernels. The default one is the one highlighted, and if it doesn’t include the word “xen” with it, most likely that we have found the problem.

We now need to change to a PV-capable kernel. We will need to access the “/boot” partition of the Linux VM, and change GRUB’s options there.

First we map the disk to a loop device, so we can access its partitions:

losetup /dev/loop1 /dev/VG_XenStorage-4aa20fc2-fd92-20c2-c549-bed2597c622b/LV-90524af4-5b20-4412-9bfe-f1fe27f220b1

Notice that you need to use the entire path to the LV, that the LV is online, and that loop1 is not in use. If it is, you will have a message saying something like “LOOP_SET_FD: Device or resource busy”

Now we need to access its partitions. We will map them using ‘kpartx’ to /dev/mapper/ devices. Notice we’re using the same loop device name:

kaprtx -a /dev/loop1

Now, new files present themselves in /dev/mapper:

ls -la /dev/mapper/
total 0
drwxr-xr-x  2 root root     220 Oct 24 12:39 .
drwxr-xr-x 14 root root   16560 Oct 24 12:31 ..
crw——-  1 root root  10, 62 Sep 29 10:15 control
brw-rw—-  1 root disk 252,  5 Oct 24 12:39 loop1p1
brw-rw—-  1 root disk 252,  6 Oct 24 12:39 loop1p2
brw-rw—-  1 root disk 252,  7 Oct 24 12:39 loop1p3

Usually, the first partition represents /boot, so we can now mount it and work on it:

mount /dev/mapper/loop1p1 /mnt

All we need to do is edit /mnt/grub/menu.lst to match our requirements, and then wrap everything back up:

umount /mnt

kpartx -u /dev/loop1

losetup -d /dev/loop1

We don’t have to change the LV to offline, because the XenServer will activate it if it’s not, however, we could do it, to be on the safe side:

lvchange -an /dev/VG_XenStorage-4aa20fc2-fd92-20c2-c549-bed2597c622b/LV-90524af4-5b20-4412-9bfe-f1fe27f220b1

Now we can activate the VM, and see it boot successfully.

This whole process takes several minutes the first time, and even less later.

I hope this helps.

It has been a long while, I know. I was busy with life, work and everything around it. Not much worth mentioning.

This, however, is something else.

I have discovered an issue with Citrix XenServer 5.0 (probably the case with 5.5, but I have other issues with that release) using NetApp through NetApp API SR – Any non XenServer-generated snapshot will be deleted as soon as any snapshot-related action would be performed on that volume. Meaning that if I had manually created a snapshot called “1111″ (short and easy to recognize, especially with all these UUID-based volumes, LUNs and snapshot names XenServer uses…), the next time anyone would create a snapshot of a machine which has a disk (VDI) on this specific volume, the snapshot, my snapshot, “1111″ will be removed under that specific volume. The message seen in /var/log/SMlog would look like this:

Removing unused snap (1111)

While under normal operation, this does not matter much, as non-XenServer snapshots have little value, when using NetApp SnapMirror technology, the mechanism works a bit differently.

It appears that the SnapMirror system takes snapshots with predefined names (non-XenServer UUID type, luckily for us all). These snapshots include the entire changes performed since the last SnapMirror snapshots, and are used for replication. Unfortunately, XenServer deletes them. No SnapMirror snapshots, well, this is quite obvious, is it not? No SnapMirror…

We did not detect this problem immediately, and I should take the blame for that. I had to define a set of simple trial and error tests, as described above, instead of battling with a system I did not quite follow at that time – NetApp SnapMirror. Now I do, however, and I have this wonderful insight which can make your personal life, if you had issues with SnapMirror and XenServer, and did not know how to make it work, better. This solution cannot be an official one, due to its nature, which you will understand shortly. This is a personal patch for your pleasure, based on the hard fact that SnapMirror uses a predefined name for its snapshots. This name, in my case, is the name of the DR storage device. You must figure out what name is being used as part of the snapshot naming convention on your own site. Search for my ‘storagedr’ phrase, and replace it with yours.

This is the diff file for /opt/xensource/sm/NETAPPSR.py . Of course – back up your original file. Also – this is not an official patch. It was tested to function correctly on XenServer 5.0, and it will not work on XenServer 5.5 (since NETAPPSR.py is different). Last warning – it might break on the next update or upgrade you have for your XenServer environment, and if that happens, you better monitor your SnapMirror status closely then.

400,403c400,404
<                     util.SMlog("Removing unused snap (%s)" % val)
<                     out = netapplib.fvol_snapdelete_wrapper(self.sv, val, volname)
<                     if not na_test_result(out):
<                         pass
---
> 		    if 'storagedr' not in val:
>                     	util.SMlog("Removing unused snap (%s)" % val)
>                     	out = netapplib.fvol_snapdelete_wrapper(self.sv, val, volname)
>                     	if not na_test_result(out):
>                         	pass

Hope it helps!

XenServer is a wonderful tool. One of the better parts of it is its powerful scripting language, powered by the ‘xe’ command.

In order to capture a mass of snapshots, you can either do it manually from the GUI, or scripted. The script supplied below will include shell functions to capture Quiesce snapshots, and it that fails, normal snapshots of every running VM on the system.

Reason: NetApp SnapMirror, or other backup (maybe for later export) scheduled actions.

#!/bin/bash
# This script will supply functions for snapshotting and snapshot destroy including disks
# Written by Ez-Aton
# Visit my web blog for more stuff, at http://run.tournament.org.il
 
# Global variables:
UUID_LIST_FILE=/tmp/SNAP_UUIDS.txt
 
# Function
function assign_all_uuids () {
	# Construct artificial non-indexed list with name (removing annoying characters) and UUID
	LIST=""
	for UUID in `xe vm-list power-state=running is-control-domain=false | grep uuid | awk '{print $NF}'`
	do
		NAME=`xe vm-param-get param-name=name-label uuid=$UUID | tr ' ' _ | tr -d '(' | tr -d ')'`
		LIST="$LIST $NAME:$UUID"
	done
	echo $LIST
}
 
function take_snap_quiesce () {
	# We attempt to take a snapshot with quench
	# Arguments: $1 name ; $2 uuid
	# We attempt to snapshot the machine and set the value of snap_uuid to the snapshot uuid, if successful.
	# Return 1 if failed
 
	if SNAP_UUID=`xe vm-snapshot-with-quiesce vm=$2 new-name-label=${1}_snapshot`
	then
		# echo "Snapshot-with-quiesce for $1 successful"
		return 0
	else
		echo "Snapshot-with-quiesce for $1 failed"
		return 1
	fi
}
 
function take_snap () {
	# We attempt to take a snapshot
	# Arguments: $1 name ; $2 uuid
	# We attempt to snapshot the machine and set the value of snap_uuid to the snapshot uuid, if successful.
	# Return 1 if failed
 
	if SNAP_UUID=`xe vm-snapshot vm=$2 new-name-label=${1}_snapshot`
	then
		#echo "Snapshot for $1 successful"
		echo $SNAP_UUID
		return 0
	else
		echo "Snapshot-with-quiesce for $1 failed"
		return 1
	fi
}
 
function stop_ha_template () {
	# Templates inherit their settings from the origin
	# We need to turn off HA
	# $1 : Template UUID
	if [ -z "$1" ]
	then
		echo "Missing template UUID"
		return 1
	fi
	xe template-param-set ha-always-run=false uuid=$1
}
 
function get_vdi () {
	# This function will get a space delimited list of VDI UUIDs of a given snapshot/template UUID
	# Arguments: $1 template UUID
	# It will also verify that each VBD is an actual snapshot
	if [ -z "$1" ]
	then
		echo "No arguments? We need the template UUID"
		return 1
	fi
	VDIS=""
	for VBD in `xe vbd-list vm-uuid=$1 | grep ^uuid | awk '{print $NF}'`
	do
		echo "VBD: $VBD"
		if [ ! `xe vbd-param-get param-name=type uuid=$VBD` = "CD" ]
		then
			CUR_VDI=`xe vdi-list vbd-uuids=$VBD | grep ^uuid | awk '{print $NF}'`
			if `xe vdi-param-get uuid=$CUR_VDI param-name=is-a-snapshot`
			then
				VDIS="$VDIS $CUR_VDI"
			else
				echo "VDI is not a snapshot!"
				return 1
			fi
			CUR_VDI=""
		fi
	done
	echo $VDIS
}
 
function remove_vdi () {
	# This function will get a list of VDIs and remove them
	# Carefull!
	for VDI in $@
	do
		if xe vdi-destroy uuid=$VDI
		then
			echo "Success in removing VDI $VDI"
		else
			echo "Failure in removing VDI $VDI"
			return 1
		fi
	done
}
 
function remove_template () {
	# This funciton will remove a template
	# $1 template UUID
	if [ -z "$1" ]
	then
		echo "Required UUID"
		return 1
	fi
	xe template-param-set is-a-template=false uuid=$1
	if ! xe vm-uninstall force=true uuid=$1
	then
		echo "Failure to remove VM/Template"
		return 1
	fi
}
 
function remove_all_template () {
	# This function will completely remove a template
	# The steps are as follow:
	# $1 is the UUID of the template
	# Calculate its VDIs
	# Remove the template
	# Remove the VDIs
	if [ -z "$1" ]
	then
		echo "No Template UUID was supplied"
		return 1
	fi
	# We now collect the value of $VDIS
	get_vdi $1
	if [ "$?" -ne "0" ]
	then
		echo "Failed to get VDIs for Template $1"
		return 1
	fi
	if ! remove_template $1
	then
		echo "Failure to remove template $1"
		return 1
	fi
	if ! remove_vdi $VDIS
	then
		return 1
	fi
}
 
function create_all_snapshots () {
	# In this function we will run all over $LIST and create snapshots of each machine, keeping the UUID of it inside a file
	# $@ - list of machines in the $LIST format
	if [ -f $UUID_LIST_FILE ]
	then
		mv $UUID_LIST_FILE $UUID_LIST_FILE.$$
	fi
	for i in $@
	do
		SNAP_UUID=`take_snap_quiesce ${i%%:*} ${i##*:}`
		if [ "$?" -ne "0" ]
		then
			echo "Problem taking snapshot with quiesce for ${i%%:*}"
			echo "Attempting normal snapshot"
			SNAP_UUID=`take_snap ${i%%:*} ${i##*:}`
			if [ "$?" -ne "0" ]
                	then
                        	echo "Problem taking snapshot for ${i%%:*}"
				SNAP_UUID=""
			fi
		fi
		stop_ha_template $SNAP_UUID
		echo $SNAP_UUID >> $UUID_LIST_FILE
	done
}

Possible use will be like this:

. /usr/local/bin/xen_functions.sh

create_all_snapshots `assign_all_uuids` &> /tmp/snap_create.log